Tips for Small and Local Businesses to Create Effective Direct Mail Advertising Campaigns in 2023

With the right design and messaging, your campaigns can create a positive impression and drive action

Tips for Small and Local Businesses to Create Effective Direct Mail Advertising Campaigns in 2023

2085 1371 Mailjoy blog

Direct mail advertising is an effective way for small and local businesses to acquire new customers. Unlike email campaigns, direct mail is a physical, tangible form of communication that has a higher response rate. According to the 2022 State of Direct Mail study, direct mail has a 13x higher response rate compared to email campaigns. When combined with email campaigns, the response rate increases to 27x higher. In this article, we will provide practical advice for small and local businesses to create effective direct mail advertising campaigns.

The Benefits of Direct Mail Advertising Over Email Campaigns

As mentioned, direct mail advertising has a higher response rate compared to email campaigns. The tangible nature of direct mail allows recipients to physically hold and engage with the content, making it more memorable and impactful. Additionally, direct mail campaigns offer greater targeting capabilities. By utilizing data and analytics, businesses can tailor their message to specific demographics, interests, and behaviors of their target audience.

In addition to the higher response rate, direct mail campaigns offer other benefits compared to email campaigns. For one, direct mail campaigns have a longer lifespan. While emails can be easily deleted or marked as spam, direct mail pieces can stay in a recipient’s home or office for days or even weeks, serving as a constant reminder of the message and offer. Additionally, direct mail allows for more creative and eye-catching designs, which can help your business stand out from the competition and increase engagement. With the right design and messaging, you can create a direct mail campaign that not only captures attention but also creates a positive impression and drives action.

Tips for Targeting the Right Audience and Personalizing Messages

Before creating a direct mail campaign, it’s crucial to identify and target the right audience. This requires research and data analysis to understand the demographics and behaviors of potential customers. Once identified, businesses can personalize their message to create a more impactful and engaging campaign. Personalization can be as simple as using the recipient’s name or as complex as adding custom images to create a unique experience for each recipient.

One effective way to target the right audience is to create a customer persona. A customer persona is a detailed profile of an ideal customer based on demographic information, interests, and behaviors. By creating a persona, businesses can better understand their target audience and tailor their message to meet their specific interests. This can significantly increase engagement and response rates, as customers are more likely to respond to a message that resonates with their needs and interests.

Another important factor in targeting the right audience is the mailing list itself. Businesses can obtain a mailing list from a variety of sources, including list brokers, public records, and in-house customer data. It’s important to ensure that the list is accurate and up-to-date, as mailing to outdated or incorrect addresses can result in wasted resources and decreased effectiveness. Businesses should also segment their mailing list based on criteria such as location, interests, and purchase history, and tailor their message and offer accordingly for each group. By targeting the right audience and personalizing the message, businesses can create a direct mail campaign that resonates with customers and drives results.

Examples of Successful Direct Mail Campaigns and Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Test Variations

Not all direct mail campaigns are successful. One common pitfall is not testing multiple versions of the campaign to determine which message and design resonate best with the target audience.

Testing is an essential part of any effective direct mail campaign. By testing different versions of the message and design, businesses can determine which elements resonate best with their target audience and optimize their campaign for maximum effectiveness. There are several ways you can test a direct mail campaign, including A/B testing, where different versions of the message or design are sent to two groups of recipients, and multivariate testing, where multiple variables are tested simultaneously to determine the optimal combination.

A/B testing is a common method for testing direct mail campaigns. In this method, you create two versions of the campaign, with one variable changed between the two versions, such as the headline or offer. You then send the two versions to two groups of recipients, with the results compared to determine which version is more effective. A/B testing can be repeated multiple times with different variables to further refine the campaign. By testing different versions of the campaign, businesses can gain valuable insights into what resonates best with their target audience and use that knowledge to optimize their campaign for maximum effectiveness.

Measure your Campaigns

Another pitfall is not tracking conversions and measuring the success of the campaign. This is essential for determining its effectiveness and identifying areas for improvement. One easy way to track conversions is to include a discount code that is unique to the campaign. By tracking how many recipients use the coupon, businesses can determine the conversion rate and ROI of the campaign. It’s also important to track other metrics, such as response rate, engagement, and customer acquisition cost, to get a complete picture of the campaign’s success.

To measure the success of a direct mail campaign, businesses should set clear goals and KPIs before launching the campaign. These goals could be specific, such as increasing sales or customer acquisition, or more general, such as increasing brand awareness or engagement. By measuring progress against these goals and KPIs, businesses can determine the overall effectiveness of the campaign and identify areas for improvement. It’s also important to refine future campaigns based on the results of previous campaigns. By analyzing the data and insights gained from previous campaigns, businesses can make data-driven decisions that optimize future campaigns for maximum effectiveness.

Be Consise

Finally, adding too much information to a design can overwhelm the recipient and reduce the impact of the message.

When designing a direct mail piece, it’s important to strike a balance between providing enough information to convey your message and not overwhelming the recipient. Too much information can cause the recipient to lose interest or become confused, ultimately reducing the effectiveness of the campaign. It’s important to focus on the most important information and communicate it clearly and concisely. Consider using bullet points or headlines to make important information stand out and be easily digestible.

On the other hand, including too little information can also harm the effectiveness of a direct mail campaign. Recipients must have enough information to take action, whether it’s visiting your website, calling you, or visiting your location. Failing to provide enough information can leave recipients with questions and reduce the likelihood of a response. It’s important to find the right balance between providing enough information and not overwhelming the recipient. Consider including a clear call to action and providing contact information for more information or questions.

The Importance of a Clear Call to Action and Using Incentives and Offers

A clear call to action is essential for any direct mail campaign. Recipients need to know what action they should take after receiving the mail. Whether it’s visiting a website, making a purchase, or scheduling appointments, the call to action should be clear and concise. Incentives and offers can also entice recipients to respond to the call to action. For example, offering a discount or free trial can increase the likelihood of a conversion.

Personalized URLs, or PURLs, are an effective way to track conversions in direct mail campaigns. A PURL is a unique website address that is personalized for each recipient of a direct mail piece (and can even be used for unique/variable QR codes on your mailer design). When the recipient visits the website (or scans the QR code), the PURL can track their activity on the site. This allows you to better understand the effectiveness of your direct mail campaigns and refine future campaigns. Tools like Google Analytics can be used to track and analyze the data collected from PURLs.

Using PURLs can also provide a more personalized experience for the recipient, which can increase engagement and response rates. When the website is personalized to the recipient’s interests and behaviors, they are more likely to spend time on the site and take action. Additionally, the use of PURLs can provide valuable data for businesses to improve their targeting and personalization efforts. By tracking the behavior of recipients on your website, you can better understand their interests and behaviors, and use that information to improve future campaigns.

There are services such as Purlem that can generate PURLS and landing pages for you, or alternatively if you are using a Direct Mail platform like Mailjoy, the ability to create PURLS (or conversion urls) and variable QR codes are built right into the self-service designer.

Easily add conversion tracking to any Mailjoy design
Mailjoy’s built-in designer can insert dynamic URLS and QR codes automatically

Using Personalization to Create a Custom Experience for Your Recipients

Personalization is an effective way to create a unique message for each recipient. Merge tags are a common tool used for personalization in direct mail campaigns. These tags, enclosed in {{curly braces}} can be used to dynamically insert recipient-specific information, such as their name, location, or other custom data, into the mailer design. Personalization can also extend beyond the message itself and be used to tailor the offer, call to action, or even images to the recipient’s preferences.

You can use personalization by utilizing existing customer data or by collecting new data through surveys, quizzes, or other interactions. By gathering this data, businesses can create more targeted and effective direct mail campaigns. For example, a clothing retailer could send a personalized mailer with product recommendations based on the recipient’s past purchase history or browsing behavior. The mailer could also include a unique offer or discount code based on the recipient’s preferences or loyalty status.

Live preview of personalized postcards
Live preview of personalized postcards

Measuring Effectiveness and Refining Future Direct Mail Campaigns

Measuring the effectiveness of a direct mail campaign is crucial for refining future campaigns. Tracking conversions and response rates can help businesses understand what is working and what isn’t. This data can also help businesses refine their target audience and personalize their message for greater impact.

To measure effectiveness, businesses should track key performance indicators such as conversion rate, response rate, and return on investment. These metrics can help businesses determine if their campaign was successful and identify areas for improvement.

Once the effectiveness of your campaign has been measured, you can use this data to further refine future campaigns. By analyzing the data, businesses can identify which messages, designs, and incentives resonate best with their target audience. You can use this data to create more impactful campaigns in the future.

Direct mail campaign tracking

In conclusion, direct mail advertising is an effective way for small and local businesses to acquire new customers. By utilizing data and analytics, you can target the right audience and personalize your message for greater impact. You should learn from successful campaigns, avoid common pitfalls, and use a clear call to action to increase response rates. Additionally, businesses can utilize variable data printing to personalize campaigns and measure effectiveness to refine future campaigns. By following these tips, small and local businesses can create effective direct mail advertising campaigns and acquire new customers.

Putting These Tips into Action

Now it’s time for you to put these tips into action… And look no further than Mailjoy. With our easy-to-use platform, you can design and send professional direct mail campaigns, and track performance every step of the way. So, sign up today to take your direct mail campaigns to the next level.